By any procedure, Bugsnax is a ridiculous video game. You live in a world of Sesame Street-like beasts, and go to an island filled with bugs formed like treats – hotdogs, soda cans, and more. The googly-eyed occupants inexplicably want to consume these bugsnax, which change their limbs into the things they’ve feasted on. This procedure is called “snakification,” and for some factor, it thrills instead of frightens everybody. You should bring the spread townsfolk back together, typically by catching specific animals and feeding them to people, even as ridiculous melodramas play out in between the characters. It is as odd as it sounds.

While that produces an uncommon wrapper, Bugsnax is truly a puzzle-solving experience video game. You roam a number of fairly little open locations from a first-person viewpoint, scanning and bagging the little walking morsels by drawing, trapping, or fooling them. Along the method, you are familiar with numerous unique island occupants, and unwind a secret about the missing out on creator of the settlement.

The easy going however deeply odd premise isn’t always enough to keep the story engaging, and there’s a lot of borderline-nonsensical spoken dialogue as you meet and problem-solve for the eccentric cast. When the storytelling works, it’s because everything is communicated through such an earnest and wholesome delivery. All the flawed characters are lonely, and themes around the value of community and relationships make for a heartfelt message. Whether it’s the guy who tries to understand if his longtime roommate is really his boyfriend or not, or the husband and wife who love each other despite being completely different, everyone is struggling to connect. And also, struggling to make puns. So many puns.  

To reunite everyone, you have to hunt down and capture the adorable and tasty bugsnax, and several dozen varieties across the island each have different behaviors to decipher, which is initially a compelling hook. The puzzles start out extremely simple, and ramp up to be moderately challenging by the end. However, the challenge often comes through convoluted action and tool combinations that don’t always make a lot of sense. Sometimes, I stumbled onto a solution through trial and error, or found the correct answer, however failed because of the finicky way the hunting tools worked. From swinging nets to launching springboards, it can be fun to put together a multi-step plan to lure the burning hot stew creature to the freezing popsicle insect that will cool it down enough to pick up, but more often than not, the process just feels tedious.

The quest structure doesn’t help, as the absurd property (I need to eat that bug!) leads to increasingly inane tasks prescribed by the helpless island denizens. With each passing quest, I felt less like a brave island explorer, and more like one of those grocery shipment people who hurriedly gathers apples at the store before rushing out to hand them over to impatient customers waiting at home. Even so, I appreciate that there’s a wide selection of available quests to uncover. You can mainline the core campaign in a few hours, but if you fall in love with these little bugsnax, a number of side quests offer more opportunities for digging back in.

Between character narratives, multiple active questlines, and a whole taxonomy of bugsnax, you have a lot to keep track of. I was pleased to find a smartly organized set of collections and tracking options in the pause menu; from scan data to details on the characters and locations uncovered, it helps the game feel cohesive and manageable.

Playing on PS5, I was also impressed with the early implementation of the built-in hint system. Through both written and video guides, players can glean puzzle solutions with the touch of a few buttons, rather than requiring that you look up an answer online. It’s a small but meaningful addition in a game like this, especially knowing that the game might be targeting some less experienced users who may value some help on more obtuse or challenging creature captures.

As a game, Bugsnax seems delighted by its own ridiculous premise, and hopes its players climb onboard as well. I appreciate its genuine and childlike styles, but much of the humor never truly lands, and some late-game story threads around depression and abandonment are especially incongruous. With quests and puzzles that feel less like discoveries and more like errands, I’m left applauding a particularly entertaining idea, however one that never ever coalesces into a fun time.